The Quick Answer: It Depends on What’s Hooked Up to Your House
If you’re trying to budget for this winter in Delaware County, the honest answer is that your heating bill depends less on the weather and more on which fuel your house happens to run on. A natural gas home in Media or Swarthmore and an oil-heated farmhouse out near West Grove or Chadds Ford can see very different bills for the exact same square footage and the exact same thermostat setting. That’s because the fuel itself, not just the size of your house, drives most of the monthly cost difference.
Generally, natural gas runs the cheapest per unit of heat delivered in this region, electric heat pumps land in the middle and keep getting more competitive as equipment efficiency improves, and heating oil and propane customers pay a real premium over gas, simply because of how those fuels are priced and delivered. Electric resistance heat, the old-school baseboard or wall-unit setup still found in some older Delco rowhomes and additions, is almost always the most expensive way to stay warm.
Fuel prices move week to week, and your actual bill depends on your specific usage, your thermostat habits, your insulation, and your equipment’s efficiency rating. National calculators can’t account for any of that. What we can tell you, as a crew that works inside Delco houses every week, is which fuel tier your house falls into and what actually moves the needle on your bill.
Why Heating Costs Vary So Much From One Delco Neighborhood to the Next
This is the part the national cost calculators completely miss, and it’s the reason a blanket “average heating cost” number is almost useless here. Delaware County’s housing stock isn’t uniform, and neither is its gas main coverage.
- Older boroughs with established gas mains. Towns like Media, Ridley, Lansdowne, and Upper Darby’s denser sections have had natural gas infrastructure in place for decades. Most homes here heat with gas furnaces or boilers, which puts them in the cheapest fuel tier by default.
- Rural and exurban pockets without gas mains. Parts of Chester Heights, Concord, Thornbury, and other lower-density townships were never connected to a gas main, often because running the line out that far never penciled out for the utility. Homeowners there heat with delivered fuel: heating oil or propane, both stored in a tank on the property and both priced well above piped-in gas.
- Mixed-vintage housing. A lot of Delco homes were built, expanded, or renovated in stages. It’s common to find a house with a gas furnace for the main living space and an electric baseboard loop in a converted attic or sunroom addition, which blends two fuel costs into one bill.
- Home age and envelope. Older Delco homes, especially the twins and rowhomes common in the eastern part of the county, often have less insulation and leakier envelopes than newer construction, so they lose heat faster regardless of fuel type.
If you’re on oil or propane because your street never got a gas main, you’re not imagining the premium. It’s real, and it’s the single biggest reason your neighbor two towns over with gas service pays less than you do for the same size house.
Cost Comparison: Fuel Type by Home Size
Here’s how the four main fuel types used in Delco homes generally rank against each other, from least expensive to most expensive to run, across the three home sizes we see most often in this market. Exact dollar figures shift with current fuel prices, so treat this as a ranking of what tier your house sits in, not a fixed bill.
1,500 Sq Ft Home
- Natural gas furnace, 95% AFUE: lowest cost tier
- Heat pump (electric): low-to-mid cost tier, varies with outdoor temperature
- Natural gas furnace, 80% AFUE: mid cost tier
- Propane furnace: mid-to-high cost tier
- Heating oil furnace: high cost tier
- Electric resistance heat: highest cost tier
2,500 Sq Ft Home
The same ranking holds, but the gap between the cheapest and most expensive fuel widens as square footage goes up, because a bigger house simply needs more fuel to hold temperature no matter which source you’re burning or drawing from. This is usually where Delco homeowners on oil or propane first start asking us about switching.
3,500 Sq Ft Home
At this size, the fuel-type gap becomes the single largest line item in the comparison, often larger than the difference between a well-maintained and a poorly-maintained system of the same fuel type. If your 3,500 square foot house is on oil or propane, your fuel bill alone can rival what a gas household pays for fuel plus a tune-up.
Want the number for your exact house instead of a tier? That’s what a free in-home heating audit is for, and we cover that at the bottom of this page.
How Furnace Age and AFUE Rating Change Your Monthly Number
AFUE stands for Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency, and it’s the single biggest lever on your bill that has nothing to do with the price of the fuel itself. An 80% AFUE furnace turns 80 cents of every dollar’s worth of fuel into usable heat and loses the rest up the flue. A 95% AFUE furnace keeps 95 cents on the dollar. Over a full Delco winter, that gap adds up fast, and it applies the same way whether you’re burning gas, oil, or propane.
The catch is that a lot of furnaces in older Delco homes were installed well before 95% AFUE equipment was standard, and plenty of homeowners don’t actually know how old their unit is or what efficiency it was rated at when it went in. If you’re not sure, check our serial number age lookup guide to pin down your furnace’s install date before you start comparing bills against a neighbor’s newer system.
If your furnace is old enough that replacement is on the table, efficiency rating should be a bigger factor in the decision than brand name. Our best HVAC brands guide for Delaware County homes breaks down which manufacturers hold up well in our climate and housing stock, and where the AFUE numbers actually land for each one.
5 Ways to Lower This Winter’s Bill Without Changing Fuel
Before you start pricing out a fuel switch or a new system, there are cheaper moves that make a real dent in your monthly number.
- Change your filter on a real schedule. A clogged filter forces your furnace to run longer to push the same amount of heat through the house, which burns more fuel for less comfort.
- Don’t ignore a furnace that’s struggling to start. A unit that’s short-cycling or hesitating isn’t just annoying, it’s usually burning fuel inefficiently. A technician can usually trace this back to a dirty sensor, a weak ignitor, or an airflow problem in minutes.
- Get an annual tune-up before the cold really sets in. A dirty burner, a bad ignitor, or a system that’s drifted out of tune all waste fuel every single hour it runs.
- Use setback scheduling, not constant temperature. Letting the house drift a few degrees cooler overnight or while you’re at work, then recovering before you’re home, uses noticeably less fuel than holding one temperature around the clock.
- Check your ductwork for leaks and loss. In older Delco homes with ducts running through unconditioned basements or crawlspaces, heated air can leak out before it ever reaches a register. If your ducts are original to the house, our ductwork replacement cost guide can help you figure out if that’s where your money is going.
When Switching Fuel or Upgrading to a Heat Pump Actually Pays Back in Delco
Switching fuel types isn’t free, and it doesn’t make sense for every house. But there are a few situations where Delco homeowners genuinely come out ahead:
- You’re on oil or propane and your tank or furnace is already near the end of its life. If you’re replacing equipment anyway, that’s the moment to run the numbers on converting to gas (if a main is available) or to a heat pump, rather than just installing another oil or propane unit by default.
- Your home is well-suited to a heat pump but you’ve heard it “won’t work” in an old house. That’s often not true anymore. Modern heat pump equipment has come a long way on handling the retrofit challenges common in older Delco housing stock.
- You want to get off delivered fuel entirely and you have the right lot. Geothermal is a bigger upfront investment, but for the right property it can eliminate fuel delivery costs altogether. Our geothermal heating cost and payback guide for Delaware County walks through what that math actually looks like.
- You haven’t checked what’s available to offset the upgrade cost. Before you assume a switch is out of budget, look at our HVAC rebates and tax credits guide for Delaware County. Incentives change the payback math more than most homeowners realize.
Get a Real Number for Your House, Not a National Average
Every calculator on the internet is going to give you a number based on somebody else’s house, somebody else’s fuel price, and somebody else’s insulation. That’s not useful when you’re the one paying the bill this January.
Frontline HVAC offers a free in-home heating cost audit for Delaware County homeowners. We’ll look at your actual furnace, your actual fuel type, your actual ductwork, and your actual house, and tell you where your money is going and whether a tune-up, a filter change, or a bigger equipment decision is the right next move. Contact us to get it scheduled before the cold really sets in.